Skip to main content

Review and reactions to Alexandre Dumas's 'The Black Tulip'

pc: Cait Malilay / Type Away Cait

Talk about tulip fever! 

Obsession, 
                                   love, 
                                                   courage,
                                                                                                                       dedication...

Alexandre Dumas's last major historical novel is set in 17th-century Holland, a time when the Dutch were absolutely crazy for tulips. 

Cornelius Van Baerle stays away from politics. It's what got his godfather, Cornelius de Witt, and his brother Johan de Witt, killed and partially eaten —yes, you read that correctly, EATEN— by a mob. Below is a YouTube video that pretty much sums up the current political setting of the novel that would cause such a brutal tragedy. The book is not so much concerned with cannibalism, however, but rather Cornelius's wrongful conviction for treason, his dedication to growing the black tulip, and the supposed love that blossoms between him and Rosa, the jailer's daughter. Well, that would make an interesting in-law relationship...


What I love about Dumas is that he covers real life historical events, educating readers of the time period and setting, but also incorporates fictional characters that are bursting with life. In this case, the main fictional characters are Cornelius Van Baerle; Rosa; her father, Gryphus and Isaac Boxtel. Whether they'd be good, bad, or complex, they help push the narrative forward and make readers not want to put the book down. My favorite part of the experience of reading a Dumas book is not so much the romance aspect, but rather when the narrator narrows in on the villains' actions (his stories are told in the third-person omniscient).

Oh, for the love of tulips!

Isaac Boxtel is by far one of my favorite villains in literature. A tulip fancier himself and Cornelius's neighbor, he is upset when Cornelius, who was originally a painter, develops a love for the flowers and builds a structure in his courtyard, which deprives Isaac's garden of "about half a degree of heat," (Dumas, 44), and upsets all of his calculations. This was not Cornelius's intention of course. Dumas uses diction of accuracy and precision when describing the characters' labor that goes into tulip-growing, capturing the flower mania of that time. 

Instead of just doing what the normal person should do, knock on their neighbor's door and politely tell them that their structure is affecting their garden —I am pretty certain that, reading how kind and pure-hearted he is, Cornelius would have no problem with making adjustments for Isaac —, he becomes so obsessed with how successful Cornelius's garden becomes that he begins spying on him with a telescope! Yup, the tulip craze was REAL, and that's just the least of his actions.

PublicDomainPictures from Pixabay

If one thought that was extreme, imagine it being the last thought before heading to one's death. All that Cornelius can think about, seconds before his execution for treason, are tulips. He is saved, obviously, or else there would be no story. When he finds out that William of Orange spares his life and, in substitution, receives life imprisonment, he is a bit saddened. In The Black Tulip, the narrator says, "Cornelius, who had hoped for God and the tulip expanses of the universe, was slightly disappointed..."(94). Yup, he just couldn't wait to go to Heaven to admire all the tulips he can.

pc: Taken from Pixabay

Echoes from The Count of Monte Cristo

pc: Cait Malilay / Type Away Cait

There were definitely some similarities to his other, more famous, novel, "The Count of Monte Cristo." For instance, chapter 16 of the book, "Master and Pupil," describes how Cornelius teaches Rosa how to read and write. This relationship is similar to that of Abbé Faria and Edmond Dantés in which Faria taught Dantés everything he knew about mathematics, physics, history, and more. Not to mention, Cornelius teaches Rosa everything he knows about the art of tulip-growing. 

Check out my book review of "The Count of Monte Cristo" here!

An unanswered question...

One question that I still ponder on is, does Cornelius truly love Rosa? I say this, or more precisely, I write this, because I wonder if it's only her actions, that is, her assistance in pursuing his goal of growing the black tulip, that make Cornelius think that he loves her. He is confusing appreciation for love. 

It is also important to note that Rosa had also considered this. The narrator writes, "Poor Rosa, shut up in her room, could not know what or about whom Cornelius was dreaming...she was far more inclined to believe that he was dreaming about his tulip than about her; and yet, Rosa was mistaken," (134). Yes, he may have been thinking about Rosa, but it must be noted to the reader, that it is never mentioned that Cornelius had ever had any romantic relations with women previously because he was always shut up in his home growing tulips, and, prior to that, painting. Although readers may think, Oh, it was love at first sight when he met the jailer's daughter, one must also put into account that this may likely be the first time he's ever glanced at an attractive young woman. The only reason he had the opportunity is because his circumstances interrupted his passion for growing tulips.

Now, people who read this review may think to themself, how stupid. All that an imprisoned man can think about is tulips, he falls in love with the jailer's daughter, the end. No, no, no. It is, as I've mention before, the characters, which burst with life, that make this novel a great success. Not to mention, the obsession for tulips is quite humorous! 

Here's the version I read...

Dumas, Alexandre. The Black Tulip. Penguin UK, 2003.

Follow me on Goodreads!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Reading Diaries #2: On The Contrary to Freedom Nov 2024: 'Love in the Time of Cholera'

photo credit: Cait Malilay Nov. 2024 (from the unpublished drafts) "Love in the Time of Cholera." I've had this book for about 4 years now. It was sitting on my shelf unread until last Spring. I annotated the heck out of it, yet I still have yet to complete it. Here I find myself, over a year later, and still haven't returned to it. After a little over 200 pages in, I stopped because, well, I felt that the plot was just moving way too slow and the story was getting a little too repetitive. In sum, it's basically about a guy named Florentino Aziza, who is a hopeless romantic that becomes intoxicated by the beauty of Fermina Daza. He was only 18 years old. He becomes so obsessed with her, follows her, and despite her choosing a far wealthier man who is a doctor over him, he reserves her heart for her over a span of 50 years. However, that isn't to say that he hadn't had his fair share of love affairs (622 to be precise). The first time I heard about "Lo...

Recap of 'Conversations With Cait' episode 1: Kayla King on writing, editing and 'The Elpis Pages'

"Conversations With Cait," a new podcast that centers on the arts, culture and race and gender politics, is set to air on  91.3 WBNY-FM  on Monday at 7:30 a.m. Don't have time to tune in? "Conversations With Cait" is now available on YouTube  and SoundCloud . Here's a recap of episode one. For the first episode, published fiction and poetry author Kayla King  shared with listeners her journey as a writer and more about her two collectives, “Pages Penned In Pandemic,” and “The Elpis Pages,” both of which are collections of poetry, short stories, flash fiction, essays and more.  All proceeds from “The Elpis Pages,” according to King, will be donated to Planned Parenthood Action Fund , an organization which helps protect access to safe, legal abortion and reproductive rights. What's the story behind these two collectives? For “Pages Penned in Pandemic,” she began a featured interview series in summer 2020. photo credit: Golden Rose Creative “I was really...

Buffalo mayoral candidate India Walton discusses policy agendas with WBNY and The Record

photo credit: Cait Malilay In collaboration with WBNY , The Record met with Buffalo mayoral candidate India Walton on Oct. 17 at her campaign office to discuss her policy agendas. In the last half decade, Walton was involved in several advocacy groups, but the turning point that inspired her to run for mayor was during the pandemic when she was working as Executive Director for the Fruit Belt Community Land Trust. She couldn’t believe the phone calls she was receiving from the Fruit Belt neighborhood. Community members were reaching out saying that they were struggling with food insecurity and had no running water during the public health crisis. What also sparked Walton’s interest in running for mayor was witnessing the young generation calling for leaders to handle police misconduct during the Black Lives Matter protests. Referring to the incident involving two Buffalo police officers who shoved a 75-year-old man during a George Floyd protest, Walton said that she felt incumbent May...