Skip to main content

Are abridged texts really that bad?



I've heard of translated before, but the term "abridged" I haven't in my years of reading.

I was so proud of myself I thought I was finally on the verge of crossing off number two on my bucket list: "To complete a thick classic lit." It was on page 142 of "The Count of Monte Cristo" when I closed the book and analyzed the front cover more thoroughly. "Translated and abridged by Lowell Bair," it read. I've heard of translated before, but the term "abridged" I haven't in my years of reading.

Just like any other average person who doesn’t know the answer to a random question, I turned to Google. Abridged is by definition “to shorten by omissions while retaining the basic contents,” according to Dictionary.com. Omissions? Basic contents? My self-satisfaction turned into a feeling of self-disappointment. I wasn’t reading the original version of “The Count of Monte Cristo,” but rather a shortened one with “basic contents.”


Isn’t the act of supposedly choosing the most significant parts subjective? According to Lisa Berglund, the chair of the State University New York Buffalo State College Department of English, this may not be the case.

“Maybe they’re choosing the parts that work best out of context, or in a limited (classroom) context,” Berglund says. Perhaps abridged versions are made to be “most accessible to people who haven’t read the rest of the book, or that fit with a theme in the course or anthology.”

In one instance, Berglund’s class read “Tom Jones,” and she told her students that they could skip the narrative of “The Man of the Hill,” an inset story of about six chapters, because it “has no ultimate bearing on the rest of the novel.” In addition, she assigns all of "Taming of the Shrew," but she doesn't lecture on the subplot. As a professor, she objectively presents material that can be discussed in a finite amount of class time.

It is typical that in high school, students are obligated to read classic literature, some of which are very long. For the average high schooler, it can be extremely daunting. In college, one is given even more reading material especially if they decide to major in English literature. Do teachers prefer abridged or unabridged texts?

“I can’t speak for high school teachers, but I prefer not to teach abridged works. I would rather teach fewer texts in their entirety,” Berglund says. “That being said, I do, sometimes, teach abridgements, particularly in survey courses.”

Publishers wouldn’t make abridged versions if they were bad entirely; therefore, they shouldn’t always be looked down upon. There are some cases in which they are helpful. Berglund argues that abridged versions are best to be taught at introductory level courses rather than advanced level courses or “if the text is being used as a supplement to another text.” One instance in which a text is used as a supplement is if one is writing an essay comparing two pieces of writing. Suppose the thesis is focused on morals and the writer decides to mention "The Count of Monte Cristo" and discuss how it is similar and different to that of "Atonement" by Ian McEwan.

“It is essential that students know the text is abridged, if the version [they are given] was abridged by the publisher (as opposed to the professor who tells the class they can skip certain sections),” Berglund says.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Highlighting Indie Bookstores for World Book Day: Always Buying Books

Back row (left to right) Amelia Faulkner and Gary O’Dell;  Middle row (left to right) Bree Thuma and Tina Schmidt. Front row (left to right) Alyse Foley and Bob Wolfe  photo courtesy: Bob Wolfe JOPLIN, Mo. — In Webb City, 10-year-old Bob Wolfe would walk almost every day from his house to the public library. He couldn’t wait to devour the next set of "The Hardy Boys" books and lucky for him, he lived less than a mile away. “I didn't read 'The Hardy Boys,' I became the third brother. I lived them, I loved it,” he said. On the way home, he’d read one book while he carried the rest of the haul stuffed into his shirt. He was so absorbed in the story that he'd sometimes step off a curve, run into a tree or walk two blocks past his house without even realizing. Now, 74, he owns a bookstore of his own called Always Buying Books , in Joplin, the birthplace of Harlem Renaissance writer Langston Hughes. BOB WOLFE'S FAVORITE BOOK: Wolfe grew up in a family of reader...

Cait's Plate: Conwell Coffee Hall...Can we just toast to this aesthetic toast?

Conwell Coffee Hall, located at 6 Hanover Street, is a coffee shop and eatery in Life and Trust, a performing arts center.  photo credit: Cait Malilay From the moment I walked through the revolving door and up those steps, I was immersed back in time to the 1920s. I was greeted by a large art deco painting. photo credit: Cait Malilay I take a look at the menu and see the typical cafe assortment of coffee and teas, but wait...there's a whole section labeled "TOASTS?" Count me in! Being a California native, of course I'm going to order the avocado toast.  My mom orders the crab toast. Now...the beverage of choice. Since it's afternoon, we decide to go with something light, a cappuccino.  We are given a number and to our left, we see the seating area.  In the back there's leather couches and coffee tables. Spread out are rows of tables, so we see that we are going to be sitting pretty close knit with other groups. When we're trying to find a spot to sit, a ge...

A supporter of Bob Avakian (BA) and a supporter Charlie Kirk (CK) agree on one thing: the censorship of books is not ok!

Texas Republican lawmakers are on the hunt to take down books in school libraries that center on race, the LGBTQ+ community and sexual health. In a letter to the executive director of the Texas Association of School Boards, Gov. Greg Abbott urged them to be on the lookout for any books that he described as containing "pornographic or obscene material,” arguing that parents have a right to be concerned. photo credit: REUTERS/Lucas Jackson/File Photo Matt Krause, chair of the Texas House's General Investigating Committee, created a list and in a letter to the Texas Education Agency's deputy commissioner of school programs and school superintendents, encouraged them to keep an eye out for any books that might generate “discomfort, guilt, anguish, or any other form of psychological distress because of [a student’s] race or sex.” New Kid  by Jerry Craft is one of the 850 books on Matt Krause's list In response , a group of librarians started the grassroots initiative, #F...